This is a working record, not a marketing sheet. It contains the numbers we measured ourselves, the method behind them, and — stated plainly — what those numbers do not establish. If you are going to cite this data, quote it as it is.
What was tested
In November 2024 we ran a raw material analysis comparing our MIPG-12 and DIPG-16 against a conventional ester-alcohol reference coalescent. The work ran in two stages: a screening of the three raw materials as supplied, and then a comparison of the three used at the same loading in one paint batch.
| Property | Reference coalescent | MIPG-12 (Longwoods) | DIPG-16 (Longwoods) | Remark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Physical state | Liquid | Liquid | Liquid | |
| Colour | Colourless | Colourless | Colourless | |
| Gloss (as raw material) | N/A | N/A | N/A | Not applicable to a liquid |
| Texture / finish | Smooth | Smooth | Smooth | |
| pH | 6 | 6 | 6 | |
| Specific gravity | 1 | 0.95 | 0.95 | Reference above both Longwoods grades |
| Viscosity | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| Flow | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| Odour | Pass | Pass | Pass |
Specific gravity is the one measured property where the reference grade differs from both Longwoods grades. Everything else in this section is either identical or a qualitative pass.
The paint batch comparison
The second stage put all three raw materials into the same base paint — a vinyl silk white batch — at the same loading, so that the comparison would reflect the finished film rather than the liquid alone.
| Property | Reference coalescent | MIPG-12 (Longwoods) | DIPG-16 (Longwoods) | Remark |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Viscosity | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| Specific gravity | 1.2 | 1.2 | 1.2 | Comparable across all three |
| pH | 9 | 9 | 9 | Comparable across all three |
| Fineness of grind | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| Yellowish index | Not recorded | Not recorded | Not recorded | Row empty in the source report |
| Scratchability | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| Opacity | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| Flow | Pass | Pass | Pass | |
| dL (lightness) | — | -0.9 | -0.4 | Deviation from the reference film |
| dA (a*, green-red) | — | 0.2 | 0 | Deviation from the reference film |
| dB (b*, blue-yellow) | — | -0.5 | -0.2 | Deviation from the reference film |
| dE (total colour difference) | — | 1.1 | 0.5 | Deviation from the reference film |
| 60-degree gloss | 25.1 | 26.7 | 19.2 | MIPG-12 above reference; DIPG-16 below |
| Overall rating (1 = worst, 5 = best) | 4 | 5 | 3 | MIPG-12 above reference; DIPG-16 below |
Colour values are reported as deviations from the reference film. A lower dE means a smaller total colour difference from the reference; the reference is the zero point by definition, so its own dE is not applicable.
Reading the numbers
Three things are worth pulling out.
The colour differences are small, and they run the right way. MIPG-12 shows a total colour difference of 1.1 against the reference film, with the lightness component (-0.9) doing most of the work; DIPG-16 sits at 0.5. For a coating chemist, a dE in this range is a shade difference you can compensate in the base mix rather than a formulation failure.
MIPG-12 scored 5 out of 5 against 4 out of 5 for the reference grade, and its 60-degree gloss came out at 26.7 against 25.1. The gloss advantage is modest — roughly 1.6 gloss units — and it should be read as "no penalty", not as a performance gain.
The analyst conclusion recorded on the report is that MIPG-12 is comparable to the reference coalescent on a 1:1 ratio and can be used as a substitute for it.
What this data does not establish
We would rather you knew the boundaries of the dataset than found them later.
First, this is one paint batch. A single Vinyl Silk White formulation in one application does not establish behaviour across a range of substrates, pigment loadings, or PVC/oligomer ratios, and it says nothing about recoat adhesion, blocking resistance, or long-term colour retention.
Second, most of the recorded properties are recorded as a visual pass rather than an instrumented value. "Pass" means the analyst judged the sample acceptable on that property; it is not a measurement with a stated tolerance, and no test method is cited for the gloss figure.
Third, one batch of each raw material was tested, so batch-to-batch variation sits inside the noise of the result and the report gives no basis for estimating it.
Two gaps in the source report are worth stating rather than hiding. The yellowish index row in the paint-batch table was left empty, so that property was not recorded at all. And the colour row carries a ranking remark that cannot be reconciled with three grades all recorded as colourless; we have reproduced the recorded values and left the remark out rather than publish a contradiction. Both are flagged in the CSV as well.
Finally, these are laboratory results on our own material. They are not a substitute for the trial you would run on your own line with your own formula, and we will not present them as one.
If you want this comparison on your own batch
If you are evaluating a substitution, the useful test is the one run on your paint, with your pigment, at your solids loading. We run that comparison — including for the batch you already buy, so the comparison has a control. Send us the formulation detail you are prepared to share and we will tell you what is possible and what is not.
- —Stage 1 — raw material screening: the three materials were examined as supplied, for physical state, colour, gloss, texture, pH, specific gravity, viscosity, flow and odour.
- —Stage 2 — paint batch comparison: all three materials were used at the same loading in a single vinyl silk white base paint, and the resulting films were compared.
- —Gloss was measured at 60 degrees. Colour was recorded as dL, dA, dB and total dE against the reference film.
- —Each property carries either a measured value or an analyst pass/fail judgement; the two are kept distinct in the tables, and 'Not recorded' means the source report left the cell empty.
- —The column assignment was reconstructed from the source report's own remark column, which states the ranking for the differentiating rows (specific gravity, gloss and overall rating).
- —One paint batch (vinyl silk white) and one application — not a multi-formulation study.
- —No substrate, recoat, blocking or long-term colour-retention data.
- —Most physical properties are recorded as a visual pass rather than an instrumented value with a stated tolerance.
- —No test method is cited for the gloss figure.
- —One batch per raw material, so batch-to-batch variation is not resolvable from this data.
- —The yellowish index row is empty in the source report — that property was not recorded.
- —The source report's colour row carries a ranking remark that cannot be reconciled with three grades all recorded as colourless; the remark is not reproduced.
- —Laboratory results on our own material — not a substitute for a trial on your own line.
