Product Spotlight2026-11-18

Defoamer Head-to-Head: WoodsDefo BX-024 Compared with BYK-024 in a Waterborne Industrial Varnish

A lab comparison of anti-foaming ability and compatibility, run on 130 g of the same waterborne industrial varnish with both defoamers dosed at 0.2%. WoodsDefo BX-024 rated better on defoaming and equal on compatibility.

Defoamer Head-to-Head: WoodsDefo BX-024 Compared with BYK-024 in a Waterborne Industrial Varnish

Defoamer performance in a given formula is not a property of the defoamer alone. It depends on how the defoamer interacts with the resin, the pigment and the surfactant system in the base paint. The only reliable way to judge a candidate is to run it in the base paint you actually buy.

The test

We compared WoodsDefo BX-024, a polysiloxane defoamer, against BYK-024 in a waterborne industrial varnish. The test used 130 g of waterborne industrial varnish A-639 at room temperature, with 2.0% of the sample added into the original liquid, giving 0.26 g of defoamer into 130 g of base.

For the anti-foaming test, the varnish and defoamer were stirred at 400 rpm, dispersed at 600 rpm for one minute, then raised to 1300 rpm for five minutes, after which the density was measured. Compatibility was checked by drawing a film with a 75 µm wire rod on a glass plate and observing whether shrinkage holes appeared.

Results

With the reference defoamer the varnish density was 0.555 g/ml, gloss was 103.4 and the film was standard in opacity. With WoodsDefo BX-024 the density was 0.575 g/ml, gloss was 103.5 and opacity was standard as well. No shrinkage holes were observed with either product, so compatibility was comparable in both cases.

The conclusion of the report was that WoodsDefo BX-024 is better than BYK-024 on anti-foaming ability, and equal to BYK-024 on compatibility.

Reading the numbers

The gloss figures are close enough that the two products should not be separated on finish quality; the meaningful difference is in the density reading, which is the direct output of the defoaming step. Compatibility is the result most often used to disqualify a candidate, and here both products produced a hole-free film on the same base.

How to use this in a formulation

The test was run on one specific industrial varnish at one specific dosage. When you evaluate a defoamer for a different base, start from the same 0.2% dosage on your own paint, measure the density before and after dispersion, and check the film for shrinkage holes on a glass plate. Both steps take minutes and together they tell you more than a product brochure.

Where to go next

The grade specification is on the product page, and the technical questions buyers ask most often about this product are answered in the product FAQ there.